Monday, 16 January 2017

In Reply to Ian Chappell


Ian Chappell is belonged to that cricket era, when Australia was not considered any favorite amongst cricket playing nations. After retirement from the game he chose a commentating career at Channel 9, which is still continued. However, it is always his gawky and derogatory comments that have been letting him down and for that reasons he was banned twice by his parent broadcast organisation.

After the Pakistan 3-0 whitewash in Australia his remarks to ask the Cricket Australia not to invite Pakistan any further until  the Asian side raise their standards significantly and offer some sort of challenge to the Kangaroos were again "uncalled for and unbecoming." I am not going to justify the national team performance against Australia in Test series, but what distastes me is share arrogance and inelegance on behalf of a publicity-starving commentator, rather any graceful and dignified criticism of a former sportsman.  

He also expects from Pakistan to "play decent cricket in Australia." Surprisingly that expectation comes from such a person who is responsible for not to let cricket remained decent and gentlemen' game anymore. As the Australians are globally blamed for institutionalising sledging in the game and Ian Chappell is called the pioneer of this indecency. He admits that in his writings, "As a captain my philosophy is simple between 11:00 am to 6:00 pm there was no time to be a nice guy."  Keeping aside that he is belonged to a family which is notoriously famed for stigma of “Under-arm” bowling in cricket, sledging alone has made the book of ICC Code of Ethics even thicker and more liable.

He was also critical of captain Misbah ul Haq by saying, “A lot of their (Pakistan cricket team) problems was because they had no leadership. There was no inspiration from Misbah, so things have got to change in Pakistan”. Forget if he is ignorant about Misbah ul Haq’ record as a captain of Pakistan, but he should acknowledge that Misbah is leading a team, which is forced to play their international cricket on foreign soil. Cricketers of Pakistan are not aware of home advantage, home crowd and home conditions, while contemporary statistics show that in the cricket history winning probability while playing at home has never ever been as strong as it is in recent times; and that is the truth of modern cricket.

If Chappell looked at the away records of most teams including in last 10 years he would find more defeats than wins. He should have been aware that his team managed to win just one series in 10 years, which was against South Africa in 2014. While in their away tour Australian team faced the humiliation of whitewash in Test series against Sri Lanka, India, and Pakistan in UAE and also 5-Oneday series against South Africa only in the last couple of years.

Misbah ul Haq is right in his column where he writes “If we apply Chappell comments to Australia, does that mean if they continue to get whitewashed on the subcontinent on a regular basis then they should not travel there.”     

Interestingly Ian Chappell never played any match in the subcontinent. And, his record against the subcontinent teams is also not impressive. In 6 innings of four Test, he played against Pakistan he scored 352 runs including a 196 runs inning. While in 15 innings of 9 Test against India he scored just 356 runs, which shows his vulnerability against spin bowling.

Australians always avoid play cricket out of their comfort zone. They were the first team in the late 1900s that refused to travel Pakistan for security reasons and played an avid role in making Pakistan a “Sporting Pariah”. While on the other hand despite terrorism threats from ISIS in Melbourne during the 2016 Boxing Day Test, Pakistan cricket team never gave any dam concern to enter into the field. In 1996 Australia cricket team also refused to play World Cup Group match in Sri Lanka citing the same security reasons, but for knock-out encounter it had to travel in Lahore only to lose the final against the same Sri Lanka.

He should be careful and humble in his remarks and not ignore the values of sports while speaks. 




By


Naseem Rajput

naseemrajput@hotmail.com

No comments:

Post a Comment